I last discussed this title a few years ago, in a review I
did on console. There’s something oddly comfortable about this game – so much
so that I garnered all of the achievements on Xbox and got the Platinum Trophy
on PlayStation. However, this is a game that was first released on PC, which
oddly was a platform I had never experienced it on.
I’m not really sure what possessed me to just randomly up
and install it via Steam recently, but I did and found myself falling very
easily back into the routines of this title. Now, this game doesn’t go
cross-platform. I was starting from ground zero yet again, but honestly? I’m
not sure I’d have it any other way. While there were plenty of familiar elements
to this combination idle / strategy game that I was once very well-versed in, a
lot had changed in Idle Champions of the Forgotten Realms over the last few
years, and this allowed me the chance to experience some of those changes and
adapt accordingly.
I will start with a quick rundown of what Idle Champions of
the Forgotten Realms is (though you can read my prior review for a much more
detail description). Essentially, it’s primarily and idle game. Those can come
in a lot of flavors, from ‘mash button repeatedly without looking at the screen’
to ‘set things up and let them run for hours unattended’. Technically, this
game is closer to the latter than the former, but it’s not really all that
hands off. It’s great for when I’m doing some other things, because it can and
will run without intervention for minutes (or sometimes hours at a time, like
when I go to bed or work). You are always progressing in some fashion, as your
characters meet objectives and move to the next level. At the next level they
earn more gold. More gold unlocks higher character levels, which make them
stronger so they can continue advancement.
At its heart, Idle Champions of the Forgotten Realms is a lightweight
RPG based on – well, the granddaddy of RPG: Dungeons & Dragons. Specifically
Forgotten Realms (though interestingly enough, there’s been more Dragonlance
references of late in say, their weekly event that’s taking place – more on
that later). So you have well-known characters like Bruenor and Drizzt from
established Forgotten Realms lore interspersed with characters popularized in
shows like Critical Role. These characters are the core to the game as there’s
a ton of them, and they all interact with one another and enemies in various
ways to aid in progression.
Now, ‘progression’ could be seen as an odd term to use,
because you earn tons of gold in each run, only to have it vanish at the end.
Your characters level up, but your next run on a new map starts them off at
level zero. When I first played Idle Champions of the Forgotten Realms, this
struck me as a bit odd. After all, most RPGs are founded on a principle of gain
experience and find loot to make yourself stronger and stronger. However, there
are multiple systems in place that create a true sense of progression. Gold
disappears at the end of a run, but it turns into a deity’s ‘favor’, and these
points allow you to unlock new perks (like the middle row in your formation can
do additional damage), or you can sit on those favor points and they work into
the math behind the scenes as a gold-earning multiplier on your next run. This
of course allows you more money for further leveling up your characters, even
if they did start at level one on your next run.
Additionally, there are a handful of characters who can farm
some stats that persist through runs and become a core part of their strength
over time. Beyond those, there’s also equipment, which slowly but steadily
grows in value and level and boosts the character stats as well. So over time,
even if your characters start at level 1 each time and your gold is lost with
each new run, they all incrementally improve your odds of future success.
Now, I had always had this notion that Idle Champions of the
Forgotten Realms was a PC-first game. I would read about it from time-to-time
during my times playing it on console, and there were characters and updates on
PC that hadn’t been released on console yet. However, I now realize that this
title simply works better on PC as well. That’s not to take anything away from
the console versions, which I had a lot of fun with, but I think if I had
started on PC first and then moved over from mouse to controller? I would have
found it a somewhat rough transition.
For one, on the console your ‘clicks’ just target whatever
critter is closest to your party. There were absolutely times I wished I could click
a specific target, but couldn’t. On PC? Use a mouse to target and click – that functionality
is there. Also the various menus and shortcut options for leveling and
selecting things is a lot smoother. Every now and then on the consoles, things
would get into weird states, like swapping chars out of the active lineup to
the bench and they would get hung up and force me to start / stop. Lastly,
performance issues really dogged the PlayStation in particular back then, forcing
me to restart every now and again, or it would stutter and bog down – or even crash.
None of those issues crept up on the Steam version of the game.
But what about the game itself? I had mentioned before that
quite a bit had changed in three years. While the core mechanics are the same,
the cast of characters has grown a great deal. This leads a great deal more
strategy in laying things out. One of my favorite aspects of Idle Champions of
the Forgotten Realms is experimenting with new combinations. Also, many of the
prior characters have seen tweaks. Some of those are relatively minor, others
have seen some significant reworkings. I also appreciate that there’s greater
synergy now. There were a handful of groups like the Champions of the Hall or
Force Grey out there, but there seem to be more now with stronger ties into
those teams. Heroes of Baldur’s Gate seem better than I remember them being
back then. Also with more characters come more classes and races, making some
of those abilities that tie into a specific race or class easier to pull off
now and creating more rewarding combinations.
There is also just more content in general. Two more large
regions with their many smaller zones have been added since I last played.
There’s also additional zones. Patron variants were already in existence when I
last played, creating new and challenging combinations to test players and now
there is one more patron that adds even more replay value to the existing
zones. Another feature I didn’t experience on consoles before but happened into
the middle of when I started on Steam was the idea of ‘seasons’. These come
with a purchasable ‘Battle Pass’ component where you can unlock some items for
free by meeting various objectives on a daily and weekly basis, but having the
battle pass gives you access to even more rewards. It’s optional, and I didn’t
feel pressured into buying it – but I did complete most of the objectives
(about 70%) despite coming into things mid-season. I’m looking forward to the
next one that I can hit from day one.
Idle Champions of the Forgotten Realms has always had a
strong community tie-in. I had mentioned how popular D&D shows have played
into some of the characters that have been rolled out. There’s frequent Twitch
streams that the game makes you aware of in case you want to see the passionate
team behind the game talking about strategies and upcoming features. Right now
there’s a weeks-long event called Fury of the Black Rose. This is an adventure
being roleplayed out and shown on YouTube, but one fun feature is Idle
Champions of the Forgotten Realms lets players vote on some plot elements to be
rolled out. You can see how your votes impact the livestream.
As a lifelong Dragonlance fan, I’m kind of stoked to see
that this is taking place on Kyrrn, so having characters like Soth at the heart
of it, or a daily vote asking if Miria is going to encounter Dalamar the Dark
or Raistlin (sadly, my vote was for Raistlin, but he only got 34% - so Dalamar
it is) is pretty entertaining for me. It also gives me a sliver of hope that
while this is ‘of the Forgotten Realms’ – maybe we’ll get some proper
characters from D&D lore in other worlds to show up in-game in the future? Either
way, these votes give you Reward Tokens you can spend to unlock more things in
the game, and it all just ties in too neatly to that sense of community that
D&D really thrives off of.
It would be easy to take a glance at this title and think it’s
some sort of lazy fan service money grab, but I think it’s just the right type
of fan service. It features the proper IP, but also pulls in a lot of the
community’s creativity along the way. It’s a lot of fun seeing locations or
creatures from Dungeons & Dragons, even if the presentation is fairly
simple with colorful but basic visuals and enjoyable if limited amounts of
music (compared to the many, many levels you’ll traverse). It’s a free game
with lots of options to pay to speed things up, but eventually? You can unlock
most of what you want just through grinding. If you are going to drop a few
bucks (which I’ve done on all three platforms now, to help support the clearly
passionate devs behind this title), I usually go for the familiars. That auto-clicking
is great for when you turn off your monitor and keep the units grinding away at
night. Trust me, your mouse will thank you for it.
How long will I be playing Idle Champions of the Forgotten
Realms in this, my third go-round with the game? Hard to say. It has some nice
long legs on it due to the large amount of content, and it’s not super
demanding of me time-wise. Often I have it running on a side screen while watching
something or playing a console game on my television, poking at my group as adjustments
are needed. As such, it’s a fun, comfortable experience that keeps me
entertained without necessarily asking a lot out of me at the same time. I can’t
help but think that the PC version of the game is probably the best one, and I’m
certainly enjoying my return to the Forgotten Realms.
