Are consoles going to be too online dependent?

I have a ton of reviews (some quick ones, a few longer) set to go over the next week or so, but in the meantime - I hope you all have a great weekend while I depart with these thoughts:

That title might sound odd - but keep in mind I'm not saying that consoles should not have online - I think it's a great feature and should be used.  But is it going to be taken too far in the next generation of consoles?  Based on what I've been reading, it's a possibility.

Without a doubt, one of the greatest achievements during this generation of video game consoles was the access to online community.  Some of the consoles did it better than others (We're looking at you, Nintendo Wii - here's hopes you get it right with the Wii U), while computer gamers have enjoyed this sort of connectivity for years before there was a PlayStation Network or Xbox Live.  The ability to play with friends, have conversations through voice chat, get updates to gaming content and watch player-made videos have really helped make this generation of gaming consoles the most successful to date because it appealed to a broader base of people and gave them a means of sharing these experiences.




 So, what is my concern here?  I've already had a couple of posts on here where I expressed concerns about whether or not we need the next generation of consoles this year or next (we don't) and if blocking the used game market is a bad idea (it is).  So what's this post addressing?  The talk of an all-digital marketplace.

Don't get me wrong - I do believe we are going to get there.  There were briefly rumors that the Xbox 720/Durango was not going to come with a disc drive.  That seems unlikely now, but the fact that this was even a rumor, let alone one that quite a few gamers considered at least somewhat plausible, means we are getting closer and closer to that point.  There is a certain level of accessibility to be had with downloading a game.  You don't have to head out to a store or worry that it will be out of stock.



One of the other persistent rumors is that the Sony Orbis will require a live internet connection to play any games.  We already see this in some PC games, and it is done as a means of curbing piracy or game-sharing.  While I can respect that goal, it fails more often than not.  Let's be honest, if someone wants a PC game badly enough, they will find a cracked version that circumvents this measure.  The bar is set a bit higher than in the old days where you simply needed a modified .exe file that bypassed online checks, but in the end these DRM policies just seem to hurt the legit players.


I can't help but think that an online requirement would alienate gamers on consoles even more.  For starters, not everyone has access to internet.  I know that sounds ridiculous, and if you're reading that statement does not include you, but I do know quite a few people who have no internet or really, really shaky internet who still play video games.  Also, what happens when Sony is down for eleven hours as they work on an update for the PlayStation network?  Sure, the easy answer would be: go outside and play.  Well, that's solid advice for a kid but after a full day of work if I want to sit on my lazy bum and play a title, I'd like to be able to do so with my system of choice.

There has been no confirmation to this rumor (or really, any of them to this point) - but I'm really hoping this one turns out to be completely unfounded.


Moving on, there are some real concerns about bandwidth as well.  I have run into this one several times, and I suspect it is only going to get worse.  The ISP companies are really in many ways at-odds with digital distributors.  On one level, they are often a competing service as most ISP providers are cable companies, and many people are dropping their cable television services in favor of digital distributors like Hulu, Netflix and Amazon.  I logged into PSN the other night and out of my 11 friends online, 9 were watching Netflix.

The consumption of bandwidth is only getting greater as resolutions go up, games and movies become larger in size and ISPs penalize people who consume too much bandwidth with fees or termination of service.  So while we get faster and faster speeds and the ISPs initially want you to believe it is a wide open internet highway:


In my experience more often than not, it's more like:

If games become completely digitally distributed, I'm afraid that we'll be limiting some of that broad market appeal games discovered this generation.  There is a significant difference between having an iffy connection and doing some light multiplayer and voice chat, and asking someone to download a fifteen GB game.  Not only does it affect your bandwidth;


But our hard drive space as well:


The other thing is pricing.  Don't get me wrong.  Gamestop and other companies who buy used games at a pittance turn around and make a pretty sizable profit when they resell these used games.  A lot of people dislike this practice, and there's justification for it: these companies are making a ridiculous profit and the publishers see nothing outside of the initial sale and perhaps DLC/online passes. 

I saw some online sales today though that caught my eye.  Largely because Microsoft had their Xbox Live Gold deal of the week, and they had four LEGO titles at a discount.  Thing is, that discount still priced each of those games at a higher cost than what I could find the physical disc for on Amazon.com earlier today.  You don't need to chew up hard drive space, you don't risk the wrath of your ISP and you have a physical copy you can sell or trade in later when you beat it.  Other than immediacy, there is no benefit in this situation to buying the game online.

The other example I saw was NHL 12 on PSN and Xbox Live.  The title's been out for awhile, so why are they charging the full $60 for it?  To me that makes absolutely no sense, and when I went out to Amazon again, I found it for nearly 30% off new, and nearly 50% off used.

Steam's model works pretty well.  Kingdoms of Amalur: Reckoning is 33% off this week as part of their midweek sale.  You can pick up the enhanced version of The Witcher 2 for 15% off.  Digital distribution allows the publishers to save money on things like physical copies of discs, boxing, shipping costs - unsold and wasted resources when the title sits on the shelf.  It seems like a title like NHL 12 should reflect not only its age, but savings to the publisher since the only true value to the customer at this point is the ability to purchase immediately.  Then again, if your ISP is slow, it might be quicker to run to your local Walmart than wait for the download to complete.

I do believe we will eventually be a completely digital form of media, but it won't be in this next generation of consoles.  There are still too many barriers at this point, and pushing too hard in that direction will only serve to do damage to the growing gaming community.  Hopefully publishers are aware of this and consider their pricing and practices going forward while they take these issues into consideration.

What are your thoughts on this?  Do you feel we should be moving strictly or mostly to digital distribution on consoles on the next generation over the upcoming 2-5 years, or do you also agree that we are probably closer to 7-10 years out from being able to properly handle this as a gaming community?  As always, I appreciate your thoughts and comments, and thanks for reading!
Share on Google Plus
    Blogger Comment
    Facebook Comment

20 comments :

  1. I think digital should and will grow in the next generation, but don't think we'll go strictly digital yet.

    I'm fairly torn at the moment though and there's no clear winner for me. I like Steam a great deal and am willing to give up the advantages of physical media based on sales and convenience. The same goes to an extent for the eShop, but the 'no sales' thing is wearing thin. I suspect they'll see more on this after August when retail and digital are released for the same game.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey Robert - thanks for the stop-by. :)

    I have to say the eShop does bum me out - I like going to Steam every day just to go ahead and see what's on sale. :)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Oh hell no! ;-) Just the thought of having to be connected to the net with my system to play a game is causing me to squirm. I am using my phone as a "tethered" device to connect to the net as I type this. See, I don't have an internet connection so to be required to get one means forking out around $65 a month to my cable provider. That's $700 a year I don't want to pay; not because I don't want it, but because I refuse to give the money to a cable monopoly in our area. I pay for an unlimited data plan on my sprint phone and pull an average of 8GB a month in data usage. Unless Sony or Microsoft want to get in on the ISP game and offer it as part of their "live" package, don't force me to sign on with a cable conglomerate to play your system. As far as the release of the next gen... check my blog for that answer ;-)

    ReplyDelete
  4. ROFL - Thanks for the input Chad - I know a couple of others in similar situations where they won't/can't get cable and this sort of system just would not be an option for them. As for your next gen posts - I'll be peeking at that shortly as I've been waiting for your thoughts on that. :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. To answer the question posed by the topic - yes, I think consoles already rely too much on being online and that's why I don't own any current-gen systems. Well, one of the main reasons anyway. I'm not interested in buying an incomplete game and then having to spend ages installing it, then downloading patches and extra features. I'm even less interested in full games being download-only for many reasons. Services like Steam are great to have as an option, especially for 'smaller' indie releases and things like that but I don't like the direction the games industry is heading as a whole...

    ReplyDelete
  6. @RetroKingSimon - I tend to feel the same way. I like the *option* but the idea that it may be required for download? Seems too soon and restricting. Thanks for popping in and commenting!

    ReplyDelete
  7. The eShop is a bummer in some ways. At least it's better than the Wii shopping channel, but doesn't quite catch up to real digital distribution.

    ReplyDelete
  8. @Robert - agreed. It's fun to look around in there, but it does feel like Nintendo's current online strategy (shops, game connectivity, voice chat) has just been behind this generation on a few different fronts. Good to see you poking in - thanks! :)

    ReplyDelete
  9. If there is a change in the search engine algorithms, it is also up to the
    service provider to keep a watch on such activities.
    The objective is to arrange your passions as carefully as possible with your online promotion company.
    You can then take a hard look at the companies that come up for that particular keyword.
    The only thing that cannot be "fixed" later is your blog and post titles.
    Thus, in minimum cost, you get an opportunity to increase your site ranking on Search Engine Result Page (SERP).
    The algorithms are not known publicly, but one thing is certain, is the search engine websites that
    the information is relevant to the purpose of the preferred site.
    Identify your niche audience and be an active member on
    the forums and blogs. Content writing for websites is not as simple as typing out a predetermined amount
    of words, if you wish people to view the content.
    Moreover, some companies are not able to get the desired
    results and their techniques might even have bad effects on the business's website. Be sure that the SEO outsourcing company you hire is capable of communicating properly. organic search, frequency of blog posts, frequency of on-page optimization, the relative importance of links, the use of social media, the best way to measure results, etc. The concepts make use of the current social networking sites, which are very popular among the online audience. Effective SEO techniques for Bloggers aren't any different.

    Such services also include some research that will need to be done so they can
    apply this research on major keyword. Know how to get better rank.
    SEO companies may only offer this type of service.
    The World Wide Web is an incredible source of customers and
    potential revenue for all types of businesses
    and companies in all niches. Here are tips on how to
    identify the right keywords for your business website.

    First of all a market survey is done by them as to know the competitors analysis.
    Addition and updation of fresh content always leads to arrival of increased
    traffic to your websites.

    Here is my website; 110579.redber.net

    ReplyDelete
  10. My brother suggested I might like this blog. He was once totally right.
    This put up actually made my day. You can not believe simply how much
    time I had spent for this info! Thank you!

    my web site ... onlineradio

    ReplyDelete
  11. If there is a change in the search engine algorithms, it is also up to the service provider to keep a watch on such activities.
    This means you tend to be copying it through file sharing websites like rapidshare, megaupload, hotfile, etcetera.
    The tools include efficient internet marketing, proper usage of keywords, flawless content and creating social media buttons.
    Working with an SEO expert in your country can help as SEO
    experts within the same country generally know how to optimize websites for a specific country's audience more effectively. If you simply copy the original manufacturer's description,
    you don't add value to your product and you certainly don't add your personal touch that can make you
    stand out from your competitors. Examine in detail the shift in the customers' rank, and progress in their positions. Instead, the developer should concentrate on the functions mentioned in this article first, as they are the basis for further extension of the Word - Press header file. The thing that needs to be emphasized is to create text of your website in such a way that the algorithms find them easily. The businesses have understood the need to take SEO services for attaining good search engine placement. This helps auto dealership websites rank higher in the search engines results and get more traffic to the website. Thus, if your charges are overly cheap, this might cause doubts and worries from their mines regarding the quality of the service they get. However, in general, SEO services involve using standard and compliant coding. Effective SEO techniques for Bloggers aren't any different.
    You can Google maps link for your website, which will be very helpful if any person search in images sections.
    For this reason, having mentions from these sites have increasingly become a more valuable asset for your internet marketing.
    The sooner a site is presented in the search result, or the higher
    it “ranks”, the more searchers will visit the
    site. Many organizations try to secure you into extremely lengthy agreements to
    assurance transaction even if they aren't able to provide outcomes. Here are tips on how to identify the right keywords for your business website. What is the magic formula. November 2012.

    Here is my website - just click the following post

    ReplyDelete
  12. You can also buy bundlе ԁeals, whіch mоst rаdіο
    statіons offer, to decrease the οverall аd coѕt.

    Anоthеr thing you'll need is some strength to endure, because there's a
    gooԁ chance уou'll be your own producer for the show or perhaps the best producer the show has. Proffering multifarious benefits to the advertisers, it is a quintessential resort for companies big or small.

    Also visit my blog - http://www.weightlosswithfriends.com/blogs/entry/Using-Online-Marketing-Tactics-For-Your-Products-And-Services

    ReplyDelete
  13. all the time i used to rеad smaller content ωhich also cleаr their motiνe, and that
    is also happening wіth thіs pіece of writing which I am reading noω.



    Feеl freе to visit my web рage: www.mymedialand.com/index.php

    ReplyDelete
  14. 5. If you encourage your visitors to write their original reviews about your products instead of coping reviews from competitive websites to show you have
    circulation and satisfied customers, your website is more likely to earn higher ranking in the major search engines.
    Content, keywords and link building are some of the factors using which
    Search Engine Optimization services are taken care of. While
    you’re at it, remove all or fix 404 errors.
    NOW, I don't mean you should just put keyword spam in your footer. Meta Name and Meta Description Tags are two of the important ones. Domain Authority is influenced by:. This means that they follow only the steps given to them by Google and other major search engines. Isn't that something you and your business should be a part
    of. This helps auto dealership websites rank higher in the search engines results and get more traffic to the website.
    Thus, if your charges are overly cheap, this
    might cause doubts and worries from their mines regarding the quality of the service they
    get. He has also mentioned each and every seo service. Effective SEO techniques for Bloggers aren't any different. It's
    more control than you get In many backlinks and
    every element of these controls allow you to link a bit more than he would be out of control.

    This was the beginning of the thought process for my new business.
    SEO companies may only offer this type of service.
    Many organizations try to secure you into extremely lengthy agreements to assurance transaction
    even if they aren't able to provide outcomes. A person can find all sorts of products available at various prices on the internet. Such companies know the best about industry and market trends. Yahoo style guide.

    Feel free to visit my web-site - click through the next page

    ReplyDelete
  15. I ԁelіght in, result іn I found еxactly ωhat I was taking
    a look for. You've ended my 4 day lengthy hunt! God Bless you man. Have a great day. Bye

    My page: flurtbook.com
    Also see my site - fanzooloo.com

    ReplyDelete
  16. With dozens оf radіο appѕ for i - Phonе available in
    i - Τuneѕ, there is аn app for eѵery cаtegory of music lover to
    love. While the effects of аntenna polаrizаtion may be interpгeteԁ as a reduction in the quality οf some radio linκs, some radio designerѕ often
    make usе of this property to tune an
    antenna to thеіr neеds by restricting trаnsmiѕsiοn or receрtion to ѕignalѕ on a limited number of vectors.
    Τhese include thе artist-branԁed
    music сhаnnels such as The Grateful Dead Chаnnel, Eminem's Shade 45, Jimmy Buffett's Raԁio Maгgaritavіlle;
    therе is even thе сlasѕical muѕic Metropolitan Opегa Radio
    channel.

    Feel fгee to suгf to my web page wiki.cassidie.net

    ReplyDelete
  17. you are in reality a just right webmaster. The site loading
    velocity is amazing. It kind of feels that
    you are doing any unique trick. Moreover, The contents
    are masterwork. you've done a fantastic process on this topic!

    Here is my blog - youtube converter

    ReplyDelete
  18. Hi theгe, just became аware of your
    blog through Google, and found that it is truly
    informativе. I am going to watch out for bгusselѕ.
    I ωill bе grateful іf уou continue this
    in future. A lοt of people will be benefited frоm youг wгіting.

    Cheers!

    my webѕite ... radiosender

    ReplyDelete
  19. Conѕidеr running a conteѕt or offerіng a free product tiρ sheet that acсοmpаniеs the іnterѵiew.
    (Cheсk out the aгticle: What's Really Out There in the Night Sky to see how some celestial objects appear at different EM frequencies. It is a more reliable choice when compared to traditional concrete or wooden barriers for several reasons.

    Feel free to visit my blog post; myvideo downloader

    ReplyDelete